Handpicked Holiday Gifts I Didn’t Find on Amazon
The holiday clock is ticking louder than my timer for the Thanksgiving sweet potatoes, that I am pre-baking. The grandkiddies are rolling in soon, the kitchen counters are covered with prep bowls, and it already smells like the start of a wonderful week with family gathered together.
In the middle of all the chopping and list-checking, I realized I didn’t want to let the week slip by without popping in to share something fun and wish all my US readers a Happy Thanksgiving.
I have noticed that everywhere I look online, gift guides seem to begin and end with the same three places: Amazon, Target, Walmart. All convenient, all familiar… but there’s a whole world of charming finds beyond these retailers.
So before the turkey even gets carved, I thought it would be fun to share a few of the places I personally love to browse when I want gifts with a little more soul and story behind them. A few are items I’ve added on my own Christmas wish list (hint, hint, Ed), and others are longtime favorites that have found happy homes in my house.
Let’s start with the retailer that will forever have my heart.
Macy’s
Once I open the door to Macy’s, my brain clicks straight back into the years I spent working there in the display department, first at Herald Square in New York, then in San Francisco, and later in the Philadelphia suburbs. I even marched in the Thanksgiving Parade one year, which means Macy’s will forever be stitched into my holiday memories. Maybe that’s why it’s still one of my favorite places to wander for gifts that feel both classic and full of charm.
One of the sweetest discoveries this season is the Lenox Spice House ornaments. If you remember the original village collection from the 80’s, these ornaments feel like tiny nostalgic cousins, detailed, charming, and perfect for anyone who loves a little tradition on their tree.
And speaking of classics, I always return to Shiseido’s eye cream. I’ve tried others over the years, but this is the one I inevitably come back to. Whenever I love a beauty product enough to stay loyal, it usually ends up being a hit with friends, too. It can make a thoughtful little indulgence to give.
From there, my cart usually picks up something shiny, like the Wallace silver bells. I love jingle bells, and these bells are the kind that never go out of style. I inherited two from Ed’s mom, and now I’m determined to create a little trio. They make the sweetest hostess gift, especially tied onto a bottle of wine or the top of a wrapped present.
Of course, I can’t resist a bit of kitchen style. My daughter has the Smeg electric kettle, and the way it heats water fast while looking so retro-chic makes me smile every time I use it when I am at her house.
And because I’m forever flipping through holiday magazines and catalogs, I also have my eye on a reversible plaid bedding set. I’ve always wanted Christmas sheets, and this may finally be the year I treat myself.
And for pure practicality? My favorite treasure came from a church rummage sale—a perfectly working mini oven that I snagged for $15. It is just like this Breville mini oven/air fryer. I use it every day. It preheats in a blink and doesn’t turn the kitchen into a sauna like my wall ovens do. I’m convinced everyone needs one.
Neiman Marcus
Once I’ve had my Macy’s moment, my gift-hunting mood shifts over to Neiman Marcus. Back when I lived near one, I’d wander the store just to soak in the elegance and creativity. It always felt like the place to go when I wanted something a little more unexpected, something that didn’t blend into what the rest of the mall stores were selling.
This year when browsing the site, the needlepoint pillow jumped right off the screen for me. It captures exactly how I feel about the joy of time spent with family, and I’m already planning to make a few memories with mine this week.
For the Ralph Lauren lovers in your life, Neiman’s has a gorgeous green Polo cap that fits right into the whole “elevated, classic Ralph Lauren Christmas” trend that’s everywhere right now.
One little fashion find I couldn’t resist? Fingerless leather mittens. They’re stylish, warm, and let me scroll on my phone without peeling them off. They come in black, too, but the color I chose matches my winter jacket perfectly. And if you’re familiar with the Byers Choice Carolers, their colorful Advent calendar feels like a gift a family can treasure for years.
Even when my budget was tight, I loved walking out of Neiman’s with a small Neiman’s bag swinging from my wrist filled with something I could afford at the cosmetic counter. There’s something about that elegant shopping bag that makes one feel special. Jo Malone’s Vitamin E lip conditioner is a luxe little treat that makes a beautiful stocking stuffer.
QVC
And then there’s QVC… my forgotten gem that my sister always reminds me not to overlook. It’s the place that quietly has everything you didn’t realize you needed, and usually at a much friendlier price.
Wide-beam flashlights have completely changed my nighttime lighting game. No more tiny flashlight tunnels, these brighten up the entire hallway, perfect for stockings or just tackling a dark garage.
My sister also gifted me a set of Diamonique stud earrings a few years back, and they truly pass as the real thing. Five sizes in one set means you always have a pair that works.
QVC also has a rotating Christmas tree stand that I’m fascinated by. If twinkling lights feel magical, imagine watching your entire tree slowly turn. It would be like giving your ornaments their own little parade.
For pure coziness, the pine-colored Muk Luk slippers might as well be a hug for your feet. Pair them with Christmas pajamas and you have an instant holiday mood. And because my allergies have put a pause on using our fireplace, I’m looking into the Shark air purifier with both HEPA and charcoal filters. If it lets us enjoy a winter fire again, it will be worth every penny.
And since I can’t resist soft things this time of year, I just ordered a red fur throw blanket for my living room. I can already picture myself curled up in it, watching Christmas movies with the glow of the tree dancing in the background.
As I was putting this little guide together, I was reminded how much joy there is in gift giving. There’s something special about handing someone a present that has a bit of personality to it, whether it comes from a department store with decades of memories for me, a luxury shop that inspires new ideas every time I wander through, or a surprising source I’d completely forgotten about until my sister nudged me.
I hope this post inspires you to peek beyond the usual shopping carts this season and find gifts that feel thoughtful, sentimental, and maybe even a little nostalgic.
And now… back to the Thanksgiving prep! The house will be filling up later today and I can already feel the sparkle of the holiday season starting to unfold. :-)
For all my American readers, Wishing you a cozy, joyful Thanksgiving. And for all my readers, happy hunting for finding just-right holiday gifts for everyone on your gift giving list.
Would you like to save this post?
Enter your email below and I’ll send it to you!